Group or Individual Practice: Weighing the Pros and Cons for Tomorrow’s Doctors
September 22, 2015
J. Edward Bates, M.Ed., senior director of the Texas Tech University Health Sciences
Center (TTUHSC) Office of Graduate Medical Education, invited me recently to speak
at the monthly meeting of residents. The topic he gave me was financial planning and
debt management. Since I know several of the professors in Texas Tech University’s
nationally renowned Personal Financial Planning Department, I brought in a colleague
from there to assist me in the endeavor. My friend did most of the talking that day
since these areas are his “stock and trade.”
But, I did have the opportunity to say a few things during the session and spoke about
the trend toward physicians joining large group practices versus going on their own
or with a small group. This is a very germane decision to a resident’s financial planning.
I have watched a change over my 35 years in the industry. We have gone from the day
when most doctors worked by themselves, or maybe in a small group of two or three
others, to most joining large groups as they start their practice. This change is
being driven, I think, by the rising administrative burdens of being independent and
from competitive pressures that can drive a small practice into insolvency. If insolvency
is not a problem—constant headaches from managing the practice might be.
I told the residents that joining a large group is not an escape from the financial
or management challenges facing physicians; nor, does it relieve them of the responsibility
to know what is happening in “their” business.
Often a large physician group will offer attractive compensation for an initial “honeymoon
period.” After that period, the practice will switch to performance-based pay, which
may be lower overall compensation. Of course, it can work the other way, too, and
result in more compensation for the doctor. But, the point is the doctor is at risk.
The large practice is not. This is why I told the residents to pay attention to their
charges, collections, overhead and so forth. Otherwise, they may find themselves in
an undesirable situation from a financial perspective.
TTUHSC School of Medicine does a wonderful job in producing physicians. I think it
is nice when we can talk about business issues with them also, as Mr. Bates arranged.