Speakers and writers must be careful not to make cultural references that leave the
audience in the dark. I have made this mistake on numerous occasions and continue
to do so. This concern is especially pronounced when talking with our medical students,
where I have to remind myself that most were born after 1990, and therefore, I must
choose my examples carefully.
Having said all of that, some readers will remember television commercials from the
1970s and 1980s based on the phrase, "When E. F. Hutton talks, people listen." If
you don’t know to what I am referring, E.F. Hutton is a brokerage firm that has gone
through several iterations over its long history. They are still in business, but
this particular ad has been off the air for years. The commercials depicted a young
professional in a noisy restaurant saying that his broker was E.F. Hutton, and then
he would start to quote what E.F. Hutton said. At that point, all conversation ceased
so that everyone could hear what he was he was about to say. Now, I am no Don Draper
when it comes to judging ads, but the campaign was very memorable.
Recently, I wrote in this column about the shift of a portion of UnitedHealth Insurance’s
business away from a fee-for-service payment methodology to a value-based approach.
I mentioned that UnitedHealth, because of its size, is considered a bellwether for
the health insurance industry. But, as influential as UnitedHealth is, it still pales
in comparison to Medicare.
Therefore, when Human Services Secretary Sylvia Mathews Burwell announced in late
January that the agency intends to move half of all Medicare payments away from fee-for-service
to incentive-based payments by 2018, it is a big deal. Perhaps even more significant
than the announced change in payments is that Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services
(CMS) is signaling that it intends to use its giant power to reform health care in
this country in a major way. This change has all sorts of ramifications. People in
the private sector bound to express some concern with the move because it is such
a large governmental organization. I am not taking a position, but want to emphasize
the monumental scale of this shift. It seems to me that, “As Medicare goes, so goes
the rest of the third-party health coverage industry.”
Just how large is Medicare? In 2014, it paid providers $362 billion and covered more
than 50 million elderly and disabled Americans. I have not mentioned Medicaid, which
is also part of CMS and covers even more people. When an entity as big as CMS speaks,
as in the old E. F. Hutton commercials, people listen.