When I was a hospital administrator before I came to the Texas Tech University Health
Sciences Center, I remember participating in a protected quality improvement meeting
along with several physicians, nurses, pharmacists and other health care professionals.
By “protected,” I mean the discussions were confidential and for the purpose of quality
improvement as permitted by the federal Health Care Quality Improvement Act. We were
going over our institution’s quality statistics, and the data were, for the most part,
very positive.
We were particularly proud that we had met or exceeded process standards related to
how patients presenting in the Emergency Department with a myocardial infarction (heart
attack) were medically treated upon arrival. The standards included such things as
an aspirin should be provided as well as a beta-blocker and the patient should be
prepared to be taken to the cardiac catheterization lab in less than one hour.
On a particular patient, I asked how he did? In other words, what was the outcome?
I had just heard that we had done all the steps correctly, but what I wanted to know
is how the patient faired.The nurse presenting the data informed me that the particular
patient about whom I was inquiring had died.
There were downcast eyes and nervous shuffling of paper at the response, and the reality
of the situation became clear. It became very obvious to us all that we can hit the
quality performance target for doing certain processes, but still not have the desired
outcome. Now, I am not saying that anything was done wrong, or that all patients will
survive a myocardial infarction, even with the best care. That is just not reality. Furthermore,
I understand that a myocardial infarction is a life-and-death situation. I am thrilled
that we, as a society, are doing a much better job. In the 1970s, nearly 40 percent
of older heart attack victims who made it to the hospital never left and today that
number is well below 10 percent.
However, we must match our processes with desired outcomes. Improving processes help
with outcomes, but improving outcomes is our goal. Numbers do not tell the whole story.
As a person with a degree in accounting, I believe in the power of numbers, but health
care delivery is more than numbers. It is about people who we are privileged to serve
and the outcomes of our service to them.